Submission essentials
ICML is a top venue for both theory and applications in machine learning. Reviews stress technical rigor, experimental credibility, and honest claims. The conference long uses a double-column US Letter template with strict main-text and abstract limits. Format issues rarely cause rejection by themselves, but page overruns and messy citations create a bad first impression and slow down procedural checks.
Common substantive rejection reasons: unclear assumptions, unfair baselines, weak significance testing. On formatting: watch overlong equations in two columns, tiny algorithm fonts, and mismatches between APA in-text citations and the bibliography.
Format specifications in detail
- Page and layout: US Letter; double column; main text 8 pages; references usually not counted toward the main limit (see ICML 2026 Author Instructions).
- Margins: 1 inch top and bottom; 0.75 inch left and right.
- Fonts: Body Times New Roman 10pt; titles 14pt.
- Required skeleton: Abstract, Introduction, References; other sections follow field norms and the official class file.
Writing the abstract
- Length: At most 200 words (confirm any yearly update).
- Content: Problem, method highlights, theoretical or empirical takeaways; theory papers can hint at main theorem intuition without dumping full technical detail.
- Careful language: Phrases like “significantly better” need statistics or intervals; avoid undefined “best” claims.
- Symbols: Minimize heavy notation in the abstract; when needed, match the main paper.
Citations and references
- Style: APA (author–year) with BibTeX.
- Practice: Distinguish parenthetical vs. narrative citations; follow APA rules for
et al.; clarify preprint vs. published versions. - Typical mistakes: Mixing NeurIPS-specific hacks;
natbiboptions that do not match the document class; wrong sort order in the reference list.
Common formatting mistakes
- Main text over 8 pages: Proofs or extra experiments still in the main PDF instead of appendix.
- Double-column overflow: Long equations not split with
split/multline, sticking out of the column. - Wrong paper or margins: A4 by mistake or non-official geometry.
- Abstract too long: May trigger direct revision requests from the system or chairs.
- Incomplete references: Missing volume, pages, or venue hurts APA completeness.
How to convert your paper to ICML format with AutoSCI
- Upload your paper — PDF or Word.
- Choose a template — Select ICML 2026.
- Export in one step — LaTeX, PDF, or Word.
AutoSCI applies page limits, margins, fonts, and citation formatting so your file aligns with ICML expectations.
Theory and algorithms in double-column layout
Theory papers often carry long theorems and proofs: keep theorem statements readable within column width; move full proofs to the appendix. If you use algorithm2e or similar, check compatibility with the ICML class; if line numbers are dense, reduce slightly but stay legible.
Experimental design and statistics
Report mean and standard deviation over multiple runs; align training steps and batch sizes when comparing learning curves. Keep ablation tables aligned with consistent units; if you report “relative improvement,” state relative to which baseline and as what percentage.
Anonymity and reproducibility
Remove author-identifying text and identifiable repo links for anonymous submission. The main paper should give implementation essentials; full code and hyperparameters can go to supplementary material. Disclose random seeds and hardware where relevant.
LaTeX workflow
Use the official icml style; run the full build before collaborating. Avoid loading packages in the preamble that change line spacing or font size just to “win” pages.
Pre-deadline checklist
- US Letter, double column, margins 1 in / 0.75 in.
- Main text ≤ 8 pages.
- Abstract ≤ 200 words.
- APA + BibTeX consistent.
- Anonymity and metadata checked.
- Figures and tables fit columns without overflow.
Notes for authors writing in English as a second language
Structure theory as theorem → intuition → proof sketch to avoid logical jumps.
Deadlines: AoE—finalize the PDF early.
Collaboration: Joint theory–experiment papers need a shared notation table.
Migrating from other venues
From NeurIPS single-column, expect reflow and figure resizing; from IEEE vision conferences, a full switch to APA. Structure first, then prose.
Extra FAQ
Q: Does the appendix count toward the main page limit?
A: Follow that year’s rules; usually main text and appendix are counted separately—do not stack long proofs in the main PDF.
Q: Can I shrink figure font sizes?
A: Only if still readable; do not use extreme \scalebox tricks to evade page limits.
Related work
Organize by theme and stress differences in assumptions vs. your theorems or algorithms; avoid bare citation lists without analysis.
Math symbols and numbering
Keep equation numbering continuous; if the appendix uses its own numbering, say so when you cite appendix equations.
Working with AutoSCI
Convert after the draft stabilizes; verify APA and 8-page double column. From Word, watch equation and bibliography field migration.
Review and rebuttal
In rebuttal, cite page numbers for edits; if you cut content for page limits, say which figure or proof moved to the appendix.
Ethics, data, and fairness
For sensitive data, describe de-identification and compliance; for human-related work, discuss bias and mitigation.
Versioning and disclaimer
The ICML 2026 Author Instructions are authoritative.
Supplementary material
Theorem, figure, and cross-references should match the main paper; avoid contradicting the main conclusions.
PDF and fonts
Ensure fonts are embedded; check the last page of the double-column PDF for widows and orphans.
Team workflow
Designate one “bibliography owner” for a single .bib source to avoid duplicate keys and diverging entries.
Figure readability
In double-column width, axis labels and ticks must stay readable; line styles should stay distinct in grayscale print.
Writing rhythm
Draft experiments and theorems first, then compress to 8 pages—it is usually faster than writing long and cutting late.
Common formatting pitfalls
- Using
\vspaceto brute-force layout. - Manually numbering references.
- Pasting the first paragraph of the introduction into the abstract.
Final submission checks
Verify file size, anonymity, and naming for main PDF and supplements; download after upload to confirm.
